Bookmark
Cold evenings call for this comfy chicken bruschetta bake—I'm always in the mood for it when I want something homey but a bit different. The base is everything bagels, and the top has bright flavors that make even finicky folks rave. From start to finish, you're eating in about an hour. If you're new to the kitchen, don't worry—this one's totally doable.
I originally threw this together when I had bagels left over and kept making it ever since. All those cheesy layers and bold toppings make me feel like I've made something completely new.
Tasty Ingredients
- Everything bagels: Loaded with poppy, sesame, and onion, these give a fun, savory flavor. Go for ones with a bit of crunch so they don't turn mushy
- Herb and garlic cream cheese: Adds lots of flavor and makes things creamy. Look for ones without weird fake flavors
- 18% cream: The sauce gets rich but stays light. Higher fat keeps it smooth and creamy instead of splitting
- Cooked shredded chicken: Brings the protein! Leftover or rotisserie chicken works just fine
- Roma tomatoes: Chop them up for juicy bites that aren’t watery. Pull the seeds out for best texture
- Red onion: Brings a gentle crunch—grab one that's nice and firm
- Basil pesto: Adds herby goodness. Go for the stuff from the fridge section to get that real basil taste
- Salt and black pepper: Makes all the flavors pop. Use good sea salt and fresh ground pepper if you can
- Grated parmesan cheese: Deep, nutty flavor. Freshly grated is always tastier if you’re up for it
- Grated mozzarella cheese: Delivers that gooey top. Grate a block yourself so it melts just right
Simple How-To
- Take It Out of the Oven and Let It Cool:
- When it's done, give it 5–10 minutes to rest before you cut in. Helps everything hold together for neat slices
- Oven Time:
- Place your casserole in that hot oven. Let it bake about 30 minutes, or until the cheese bubbles and the middle is nice and hot. You can poke a fork in to check the center
- Get the Cheese on Top:
- Sprinkle that mozzarella everywhere. Use your hands to make sure it's spread out so you get melty cheese in every bite
- Make Those Layers:
- Spread your creamy chicken mix on top of the bagel bits. Smooth it out to the edges. Then pile on your tomato mixture so every spoonful has a bit of everything
- Mix Up the Bruschetta:
- In a bowl, gently toss together the cut Roma tomatoes, red onion, a scoop of pesto, some salt and pepper, and a shot of parmesan. Stir enough to blend but leave the tomatoes chunky
- Add Chicken to Sauce:
- Now drop the shredded chicken into your warm cream cheese sauce. Mix well so everything's coated, then pull off the heat
- Stir Up The Cream Cheese Sauce:
- Grab a saucepan and toss in your herb and garlic cream cheese plus the cream. Warm it gently, stirring until it's smooth and creamy—no lumps allowed!
- Heat Oven And Get Bagels Ready:
- Set your oven to 400°F. Slice up your bagels into easy-to-eat chunks. Lay them in a greased 9x13 pan—keep them in one layer so they brown up and stay crispy underneath
Bookmark
The best part is always the stretchy browned mozzarella on top. My mom popped by last time I pulled this out of the oven—she wanted to know how to make it too. Now all the kids in our family ask for seconds whenever I serve it
Keeping It Fresh
Let leftovers cool first, then stash them tightly wrapped in the fridge. They'll last up to three days. For the best eating, pop portions back in the oven or toaster oven to crisp up—avoid the microwave as it can make the bagel pieces soggy.
Ingredient Swaps
Out of everything bagels? Plain or onion ones are totally fine. No herb and garlic cream cheese on hand? Just use plain, then toss in a little minced garlic and a shake of dried Italian herbs. Dairy-free folks, grab plant cream and vegan cheese instead.
What To Serve With It
This goes great with a green salad or some steamed beans. Want it heartier? Drop a fried or poached egg on top of each plate. Works at brunch or even for a breakfast-for-dinner night.
Bookmark
Fun Food Backstory
Bruschetta kicked off in Italy as a fresh-tomato topping for toasty bread, often with basil and garlic mixed in. Here, we shake up the original by turning it into an all-in-one meal with bagels as the star, bringing together Italian style and an American twist in one pan.
Frequently Asked Questions About Recipes
- → Which bagels should I pick?
Everything bagels add an herby, salty bite and nice texture, but you can toss in plain or wheat if you like those better.
- → Is rotisserie chicken okay here?
Rotisserie chicken is perfect—it saves you time and packs in flavor. Just tear it up, then mix it with the sauce.
- → How can I stop it from turning out soggy?
Scoop out the gooey tomato seeds, then spread bagel chunks in one even layer. It helps crisp things up in the oven.
- → What if I don’t have mozzarella?
Mozzarella melts easy, but provolone or mild cheddar work just as well for a twist in flavor.
- → Can I get this ready ahead of time?
Totally. Put it together, cover, and pop in the fridge for up to 8 hours, then bake right before eating so it stays just right.
- → What's the trick to cutting the bagels?
Slice your bagels into small cubes—shoot for about an inch big. They’ll soak up the sauce but keep their shape.