Bookmark
I always reach for creamy tomato gnocchi when I need fast comfort food that tastes like something special. Fluffy little gnocchi just drink up a rich, dreamy tomato sauce, and every bite is the kind that makes you wanna cozy up. It wins as both weeknight comfort and when friends come over because honestly, it’s crowd-pleasing and made from pantry basics I never have to run out for.
This started as a quick meal to chase away rainy day blues. Now, I’ll make it whenever, happily making another round and gathering everyone for just one more bowl.
Dreamy Ingredients
- Reserved gnocchi cooking water: hang onto some of the hot pasta water Thickens and helps your sauce stick to the gnocchi
- Freshly ground black pepper: adds just the right mild heat and ties everything together
- Grated parmesan cheese: even a small sprinkle gives nutty, salty taste Grate it yourself if you can—it melts in perfectly
- Dried oregano: classic Italian herb with that earthy, deep flavor
- Fresh basil leaves or parsley (garnish, optional): toss some on top for color and a burst of garden flavor Grab the freshest leaves you find
- Crushed tomatoes: get the best tomatoes you can The sauce totally shines from good tomatoes
- Salt: makes all the flavors come to life Try before adding too much
- Dried basil or fresh basil: dried is fine but fresh really perks things up
- Red pepper flakes (optional): for those who want a little kick Just skip if that’s not your thing
- Heavy cream or full-fat coconut milk: gives you that lush velvet finish Look for a cream with no weird extras
- Garlic: minced up—go fresh for biggest punch It takes the sauce from basic to craveable
- Potato gnocchi: homemade or from the store—just check they’re soft and not clumpy Even a shelf-stable pack is fine
- Yellow onion: chop it fine for sweetness and that classic flavor Look for one firm, with intact papery skin
- Olive oil extra virgin: gives a fresh, fruity base for sautéing Go for the best bottle you’ve got
Helpful Steps
- Dress it up:
- Spoon into bowls, add your extra parmesan or fresh herbs, and eat right away. Nothing beats that first creamy bite with a little green on top.
- Bring Everything Together:
- Toss the drained gnocchi into the tomato sauce and gently mix till all covered. If things look too thick, pour in a splash or two of your saved pasta water, so every piece gets coated perfectly.
- Bubble and Finish:
- Now let everything meld together on low heat for a minute or two. Add some fresh basil here if you want that finish.
- Get Saucy:
- Uncover your simmered tomato base and stir in both heavy cream and parmesan. Melt the cheese into the sauce, then taste—you might not need any extra salt since parmesan is salty. Grind in some pepper if you like.
- Hold That Pasta Water:
- Before you drain the gnocchi, quickly scoop up half a cup or so of the water and set aside—don’t skip this. Then drain gnocchi in a colander so it’s ready for action.
- Boil Your Gnocchi:
- While sauce simmers, get a pot of salted water bubbling. Add the gnocchi and cook till you see them float (around 2-4 minutes for store brands), then keep them in for a little longer, up to a minute extra.
- Sauté the Goodness:
- Warm your olive oil in a spacious pan over medium heat until it’s shimmering. Drop in the chopped onions and stir here and there, cooking five to seven minutes—make sure they stay soft, not brown. Add minced garlic and pepper flakes if you like heat. Stir and cook for another minute or two; don’t let the garlic color.
- Build Your Tomato Base:
- Pour in crushed tomatoes with dried basil (unless using fresh for the end) and oregano. Let it start bubbling gently, lower heat, pop on a lid, and simmer fifteen to twenty minutes, gently stirring sometimes. Go longer if you’ve got time for extra deep flavor.
Bookmark
I always get a kick out of swirling that final shot of cream into the sauce and watching the magic happen. My kids joke about how I sneak a bite or two before anyone’s called to the table.
Storage Advice
Keep leftovers chilled in a sealed container for up to three days. Warm it gently on the stove or microwave, adding a little milk or water so the sauce loosens back up. Skip freezing—gnocchi lose their nice texture and can go mushy.
Swaps and Changes
No cream on hand Use coconut milk or oat cream for plenty of richness. Missing parmesan Grate up pecorino or stir in your favorite dairy-free cheese. You can even swap the gnocchi for any small, sturdy pasta if needed.
How to Serve It
Make it a meal with a fresh green salad tossed in lemon and olive oil. Don’t forget some garlic toast or crusty bread to mop up that saucy goodness. For company, some roasted asparagus or broccoli are good sides too.
Bookmark
Origins
Mixing tomatoes and cream is a long-loved thing in Italy's north, where dairy is basically everywhere. Gnocchi’s been a family favorite for ages. Every home has its way. Mine’s a blend of what I grew up with plus a few shortcuts for busy nights.
Frequently Asked Questions About Recipes
- → Is there a way to skip the dairy?
Totally—use coconut milk instead of heavy cream and grab some dairy-free Parmesan to keep that creamy vibe.
- → How should I cook packaged gnocchi?
Drop 'em in a pot of boiling, well-salted water. Once they start bobbing up, wait about half a minute, then drain 'em good.
- → What’s the reason for keeping gnocchi water?
The starchy stuff in that water helps the sauce stick and get all creamy smooth over your gnocchi.
- → Can I swap in fresh herbs for dried ones?
For sure! Toss in chopped basil right at the end for an awesome pop of fresh flavor and color. Add as much as you like.
- → How do I stop garlic from burning?
Wait till the onions are soft before tossing in the garlic. Stir non-stop, just till you catch that yummy aroma.
- → How do I kick up the spiciness?
Toss in more red pepper flakes or stir a bit of chili powder into the sauce if you want some extra heat.