Mouthwatering Philly Cheesesteak Meatloaf

This Philly Cheesesteak Meatloaf packs all the flavors from the classic sandwich into a killer family dinner. It's super cozy, loaded with melty provolone tucked in juicy beef, and jammed full of pan-cooked peppers, onions, and mushrooms. A tangy-sweet topping gives a nice kick at the end. Whip this up for a cool spin on meatloaf that'll have everyone chatting.

I first cooked this up with some leftover peppers and mushrooms from making cheesesteaks and thought, why not roll it all into a meatloaf My family went wild after the first bite.

Delicious Ingredients

• Brown sugar: bumps up sweetness for a deeper finish Swap in dark brown for even more flavor
• Ketchup: brings a tangy note and color Find one without all the corn syrup for the best taste
• Beef broth: makes the glaze base Go for low sodium if you want to tweak the saltiness
• Mustard: gives that little zing Dijon’s got more punch but yellow works fine too
• Provolone cheese: melts up gooey Deli slices cover better and use sharp for a bigger hit
• Salt and pepper to taste: Throw in plenty before baking and use kosher for better coverage
• Garlic powder: quick shortcut for a savory boost Try freshly dried for max flavor
• Worcestershire sauce: dials up that steakhouse flavor Add an extra splash if you want more kick
• Sliced mushrooms: bring earthy taste Wipe and slice them right before tossing in
• Diced green pepper: adds that signature Philly twist Pick out firm shiny ones
• Diced onion: sweetens the dish Chop yellow onions small so they mix in smoothly
• Milk: keeps things soft and moist Whole milk’s creamier but use what you have
• Egg: sticks everything together Grab a big, good-quality egg so the loaf doesn't fall apart
• Bread crumbs: holds the meat together Panko has a nice texture, but go with what’s in the cupboard
• Ground beef: juicy and flavorful Some fat keeps the loaf from drying out, so go for fresh

Simple Instructions

Rest and Serve:

Let the meatloaf sit untouched for at least ten minutes That way everything sets up and cuts clean Toss a little fresh parsley on top if you wanna look fancy

Bake:

Preheat to three-fifty Place the loaf pan middle of the oven Bake cz bout forty-five to fifty minutes For extra flavor, brush more glaze on with ten minutes to go but don’t crack the oven open too long

Make the Glaze:

Whisk together broth, ketchup, brown sugar, and mustard in a tiny bowl Brush half of it all over the top before baking Save the rest for the last few minutes

Assemble Meatloaf:

Press half the meat mixture into a greased loaf pan Layer in provolone slices Lay on the rest of your meat and smush the edges so cheese can't escape while baking

Mix Meatloaf:

Toss together the cooled veggies, ground beef, bread crumbs, milk, egg, Worcestershire, garlic powder, salt, and pepper in a big bowl Use hands or a spatula Mix only until it barely holds so it stays soft

Prepare Vegetables:

Cook mushrooms, peppers, and onions in a skillet over medium heat Wait for them to soften and moisture to disappear Let them cool for a bit so your egg won't cook too soon in the meat mixture

Bookmark

I seriously love when the cheese inside turns into melty goodness and almost like a sauce. My best memory is when this hit the table on Sunday and the cheese oozed out—folks came back for more in a heartbeat. Pure comfort that makes everyone smile.

Storing Leftovers

Wrap leftovers well and stash in the fridge for up to three days. For longer, freeze in separate containers and reheat in the oven or microwave as needed. My go-to move: warm slices in a pan with a bit of water under a lid to keep them extra juicy.

Swap-Out Ideas

No green peppers? Use red or yellow for a sweeter vibe. Provolone out? Swiss is tasty for a nuttier twist. Lighter mood? Use turkey. Can't eat gluten? Grab gluten free bread crumbs—they bind just fine.

Ways to Serve

Slab big pieces alongside roasted veggies or mash for the ultimate cozy meal. Or slice for sandwiches on soft rolls with more ketchup to lean into the Philly style. At my place, we slap cold meatloaf in sandwiches the next day—always a crowd pleaser.

Bookmark

Background and Tradition

Philly cheesesteaks started as quick street bites in Philadelphia—thin beef, onions, and cheese grilled up hot. Smushing those flavors into meatloaf is a fresh twist that mashes up comfort food classics. It’s an all-in-one meal that channels those American home-cooked feels.

Frequently Asked Questions About Recipes

→ Which cheese is the go-to for this?

Provolone is a top pick since it melts perfectly and nails that cheesesteak taste, but you could swap in mozzarella or white American if you want something a little lighter.

→ Is there a good swap for ground beef?

Totally! Ground turkey or chicken work great if you want something leaner. Just pay attention to the cook time, as these proteins finish quicker.

→ What helps keep it from drying out?

Using eggs, some milk, and sautéed veggies helps keep things juicy, and being gentle when you mix stops it from getting tough.

→ Can I get this ready before cooking?

For sure. Put it all together and chill it until you're ready to bake, or freeze it if that's easier. Thaw it in the fridge when you want to finish up.

→ What goes well on the side?

Salad, mash, garlic bread, or roasted veg always work great with these bold, cheesy bites.